(*) Denotes Leading Vote Getter at Position
Catcher
- *Chris Betts, Cleveland Indians
- Jake Jefferies, Los Angeles Angels
- Gary Sanchez, New York Yankees
First Base
- *Julian Silva, Seattle Mariners
- Ramon Zaragoza, Chicago White Sox
Second Base
- *Brett Lawrie, New York Yankees (INJURED)
- Arturo Moreno, Texas Rangers
- Kolten Wong, Tampa Bay Rays
- Todd Kuhn, Boston Red Sox (Injury Replacement)
Shortstop
- *Dave Allen, Boston Red Sox
- Gustavo Lopez, Kansas City Royals
Third Base
- *Xavier Noonan, Detroit Tigers
- Kody Clemens, Kansas City Royals
- Miguel Sano, New York Yankees
Outfield
- *Martin Lopez, Minnesota Twins
- *Gincarlo Stanton, Toronto Blue Jays
- *Mike Trout, Los Angeles Angels
- Jorge Ayala, Cleveland Indians
- Jose Gonzalez, Houston Astros
- Masutaro Ohayashi, Los Angeles Angels
- Seiya Suzuki, Boston Red Sox
Designated Hitter
- *Gary Copeland
Starting Pitchers
- *Danny Hultzen, Seattle Mariners
- Mark Appel, Seattle Mariners
- Bill Black, Chicago White Sox
- Lucas Giolito, Oakland Athletics
- Justin Hooper, Seattle Mariners
Relief Pitchers
- *Victor Mejia, Boston Red Sox
- Jimmy Bannatyne, Minnesota Twins
- Kevin Clancy, Tampa Bay Rays (INJURED)
- Mark Lopez, Houston Astros (Injury Replacement)
- Matt Nevarez, Los Angeles Angels
- Ben Toder, Baltimore Orioles
- Marty Vaughn, Houston Astros
